Dr Neil Paul

The surgery building: asset, anchor or millstone?

· Also posted on LinkedIn — view on LinkedIn

Second in the How GPs are paid series — going deeper on the bits the main article could only touch.

In the original How GPs are paid I dealt with premises in a sentence: rent is reimbursed if the district valuer approves. That sentence has been doing a lot of heavy lifting for seven years. The building is one of the strangest parts of practice finance, and it’s getting stranger.

How the rent actually works

There are three routes, set out in the Premises Costs Directions, updated in 2024 for the first time in over a decade.

If you lease your building, the NHS reimburses the actual rent or the current market rent, whichever is lower.

If the partners own it, you get “notional rent” — a surveyor’s assessment of what the building would rent for on the open market, paid to you even though you’re paying no rent, reviewed every three years. That sounds like a perk until you name it properly: it’s the return on capital the partners have personally tied up in an NHS facility — the same money a third-party landlord would charge, minus the landlord.

Or, if you’ve borrowed to buy or build, you can instead have the interest on the loan reimbursed — the modern descendant of the old cost rent scheme. You get one or the other, not both, and since notional rent is often the better deal, many owners take it long before the loan is repaid; once the mortgage is gone, notional rent is all that’s left.

That — plus business rates, water and clinical waste, which are claimable if you ask — is the reimbursed bit. Everything else about the building — maintenance, repairs, redecoration, the boiler, the roof — is not covered. It comes out of practice profits, which is to say out of the partners’ pockets.

Which is why size cuts both ways. A big building sounds like something to envy. In practice, every square metre you don’t need is space you’re heating, insuring, cleaning and maintaining at your own expense, while the reimbursement only ever covers the rent. Too small and you can’t take on the staff the system is funding — in the BMA’s 2025 premises survey, 83% of practices said they lacked space for additional PCN roles, 71% were working from buildings more than 26 years old, and half said their premises weren’t suitable even for what they do now. Too big and you’re quietly subsidising the NHS’s storage. The right-sized building is rarer than you’d think.

When owning the surgery was the plan

Here’s the bit of history that explains a lot. Owning your surgery wasn’t an accident of general practice — it was policy.

The 1966 Family Doctor Charter and the “Red Book” that followed deliberately funded premises development, and the cost rent scheme that grew from it was, by the BMA’s own account, spectacularly effective: every £1 of recurrent NHS money delivered £10 of capital investment, building an estate worth around £4 billion at modest cost to the state — largely because the buildings sat on GPs’ balance sheets, not the Treasury’s.

For the GP, the deal was understood by everyone. You borrowed to build or buy, the NHS reimbursement serviced the loan, and over a career you built equity in a valuable asset. It was openly presented as an investment — a supplement to your pension, realised when you retired and the incoming partner bought your share. It also tied you to a place. You don’t casually leave a partnership you’ve mortgaged yourself into, and the NHS got decades of stability from GPs who were, quite literally, invested in their patch.

That’s where the classic buy-in came from. A new partner bought a share of the building (often via a separate property partnership, valued by a surveyor or the district valuer), worked towards parity — a full equal profit share — over a few years, and eventually funded the retirement of the partner who’d bought in before them. Selling NHS goodwill has been banned since the NHS began in 1948 (and restated for the new contract in 2004), but the property was always the real store of value anyway.

Why fewer people want the deal

The model is unwinding. By the Fuller Stocktake’s count in 2022, 49% of GP premises were GP-owned, 35% third-party landlords, 14% NHS Property Services — and the direction of travel is away from ownership. When GPonline polled GPs in 2018, 54% said they didn’t want to own premises now or in future, and four in ten said partnership itself would be more attractive without the premises liability. The number of partners fell by a quarter between 2015 and 2024.

The nightmare scenario has a name: last partner standing. As partners retire and aren’t replaced, the liabilities — the mortgage, the lease, the building nobody wants to buy — concentrate on whoever remains. NHS England’s own premises review acknowledged partners being “trapped” by estate liabilities, and put the cost of buying out the GP-owned estate at a minimum of £5–6 billion — which is why nobody has.

Here’s my open question, and I’ll admit I can’t find evidence either way. Ownership used to anchor GPs to an area for a career. As ownership declines, does tenure decline with it? You can argue it both ways: mobility might suit a generation that doesn’t want a thirty-year mortgage shackled to a partnership deed, and might make partnership recruitment easier. Or we might be quietly losing one of the mechanisms that gave communities the same GPs for decades — and continuity, as I’ve written elsewhere, is the thing general practice does that nothing else replicates. If anyone has data on partner tenure by premises ownership, I’d like to see it.

If you’re thinking of buying in

Not advice, only the questions I’d ask. Is the property in a separate partnership — and who, exactly, is in it? The tidy version, where the current partners own the building in equal shares, is rarer than you’d hope. Buildings acquire history: a retired partner who was never bought out and still owns a slice; an extension owned by a different combination of people than the original building; a share that passed through an estate. Ask for the full ownership map before you sign anything, because you’re buying into all of it.

Then follow the borrowing — all of it. The mortgage is the visible bit; practices also take out loans for extensions, refurbishments and equipment, sometimes in the practice’s name, sometimes in particular partners’, and grant-funded improvements can carry conditions of their own. When was the last district valuer assessment, and is the notional rent actually servicing what’s owed? What does the deed say about buying out a retiring partner’s share — over what period, at what valuation? And what happens if the practice merges, moves, or the neighbourhood plans finally arrive and the building no longer fits?

One more thing worth knowing: the advisers here aren’t only lawyers and accountants. There’s a whole ecosystem of specialist healthcare surveyors who work almost entirely with GP premises — rent reviews, district valuer negotiations, valuations for buy-ins and buy-outs, and advice when the ownership map has become spaghetti. Practices mostly meet them at rent review time; the better move is to meet them before you buy in, not after.

A building can still be a good investment. It’s just no longer automatically one, and the era when the system was designed to make it one is over.


If this article was useful, the workshop version is better. Howbeck Healthcare — where I’m a director — runs sessions on how general practice and the primary care marketplace work: one to three hours online with your team, or a half or full day in person, bespoke to your organisation, with guest speakers from our network of senior NHS leaders where needed. Practices, PCNs, pharma, IT and service companies all welcome. Details and contact.


Sources: NHS England — guide to the 2024 premises policy changes; BMA — rent reimbursement; BMA premises survey 2025; Institute for Government — Delivering a general practice estate fit for purpose, 2024; NHS England — General Practice Premises Policy Review, 2019; Nuffield Trust — a short history of the GP contract; BMA GPC — The Future of GP Practice Premises, 2010; Bureau of Investigative Journalism, 2011; Medical Accountants UK — capital buy-in and parity; BMA Law — last partner standing; GPonline poll, 2018. England only.