Neighbourhood Working - Part 2
Why general practice should be setting the population health agenda and how. Here’s something rarely said; general practice operates on a capitation budget. We are paid to look after a registered population, and within the partnership model the financial risk sits with us, not the system. That gives us something genuinely rare in the NHS: a structural incentive to think long-term.
If we keep someone healthy, we benefit. If we find disease early, we benefit. If we get our registers right and our prevention programmes working — the returns accrue over years, not quarters. Hospitals don’t have that incentive. Their problem is this year’s bed pressure.
I’ll be honest about the counterargument. Partners also have an incentive to protect income and manage workload — the capitation model creates the possibility of long-term thinking, it doesn’t guarantee it. That’s partly on us.
We’ve actually glimpsed what collective ambition could look like.
The early PCN Network DES indicators created genuine cross-practice accountability — practices could see where neighbours were excelling, share what worked, bring up the average. Imperfect and gameable, yes — but genuinely population-oriented. Somewhere along the way we drifted back toward individual practice performance. Neighbourhood working gives us a chance to recover that instinct. But only if we’re intentional about it — and honest about why we haven’t managed it yet: financial cycles, contracting frameworks that reward individual activity, and the gravitational pull of our own list.
The agenda should start with knowing our population properly — not by postcode boundary but at individual level. Shared data. Clean registers. Accurate coding. Welsh research showed area-based approaches reach only around 37% of actually deprived individuals. Postcode proxies are an administrative convenience, not a population health tool.
From that foundation: systematic screening that reaches people who don’t engage easily. Vaccination coverage that doesn’t plateau at the compliant majority. Cardiovascular risk identification across the middle-risk majority — where Geoffrey Rose showed us the real preventable burden sits.
And an honest question nobody seems to be asking: what’s the health economics? We spend real clinical energy getting one patient’s HbA1c from 58 to 55. What would that same energy achieve finding undiagnosed hypertensives in the same population?
PCN Clinical Directors and federation leads should be asking not “how is each practice performing?” but “what can we achieve together that none of us can do alone?” Not waiting for the ICB or acute trust to hand down a framework built around their short-term pressures.
Neighbourhood working can be the platform for that ambition. But only if we own the agenda rather than inherit someone else’s.